Supergirl Stumbles While Toy Story Soars — Your Weekly Box Office Roast

Supergirl Stumbles While Toy Story Soars — Your Weekly Box Office Roast

The Snapshot

Welcome to the arena where heroes fly and budgets cry. The new Supergirl movie opened to a worldwide take of roughly $68 million — about $38 million from the U.S. and $30 million from everywhere else. With a production price tag of roughly $170 million, the math isn’t looking pretty.

For context: films like Blue Beetle and Shazam! Fury of the Gods barely cleared the $130 million mark worldwide, putting them among DC’s lowest earners over the last decade or two. Unless something miraculous happens, Supergirl looks unlikely to out-earn those titles.

Who’s Struggling (and Why It Matters)

It’s not just about headline numbers — it’s about expectations. Big-budget superhero fare used to be a guaranteed crowd-puller, but receipts are getting pickier. When a movie costs more than it makes, studios have to make tough decisions: refunds, streaming deals, or quietly moving on.

He-Man and the Masters of the Universe is in a similar spot: a hefty budget and no signs it’ll break the $130 million barrier either. The difference? Some films get second chances on streaming platforms; others don’t. That can be the difference between a buried flop and a cult redemption.

Toy Story 5: The Glow-Up

Meanwhile, Toy Story 5 is doing everything right. In its second weekend it’s closing in on $600 million worldwide, already landing it among Pixar’s top earners. It’s not guaranteed to join the billion-dollar club yet, but it’s on the path — and that’s notable given only a handful of Pixar sequels have ever cracked that ceiling (Toy Story 3 and 4, Inside Out 2, The Incredibles 2, and Finding Dory).

Also fun trivia: Finding Nemo — the OG original — still sits high on the list with about $940 million worldwide, Pixar’s biggest non-sequel success.

Streaming Moves & Studio Strategies

How studios react to box office disappointment is part playbook, part magic show. Prime Video seems willing to back certain underperformers with a second life on streaming. HBO Max? Less forgiving in some cases. That kind of platform support can determine whether a movie quietly disappears or lives on as late-night water-cooler fuel.

Other Numbers You Should Know

Quick hits from the charts: Michael has climbed to around $977 million worldwide. Obsession sits near $370 million, Backrooms about $330 million, and Star Wars: The Mandalorian and Grogu at approximately $324 million. The Day of Revelation pulled in about $193 million, while The Furious is hanging around $35 million.

And in limited release news, A24’s The Invitation made roughly $380,000 from just seven theaters — a tidy little showing that helps the indie label breathe easy, especially after the recent release of The Death of Robin Hood.

Why This Matters to Movie Fans

Box office totals aren’t just bragging rights — they shape what gets made next. When sequels and tentpoles thrive, studios keep green-lighting franchises. When they flop, creators get more experimental… or more cautious. So those numbers influence the movies we’ll be arguing about next year.

Optional Fun: One-Line Taglines (Because I Couldn’t Resist)

Supergirl — A darker spin on the usual cape-and-smile routine.

He-Man — Toys, honor, and a budget that won’t quietly forgive itself.

Toy Story 5 — Growing up is messy, but box office numbers don’t lie.

Inside Out 2 — Emotional rewatches, now in sequel form.

Toy Story 4 — Still making us tear up in the toy aisle.

The Incredibles 2 — Superfamily business, part two.

Finding Dory — Swim on, small-screen favorite.

Toy Story 3 — Classic: still taking us “to infinity.”

Michael — A near-billion-dollar return for a pop-culture specter.

Obsession — Cold stares, hotter returns.

Backrooms — That weird, unsettling vibe worked.

The Mandalorian & Grogu — Teamwork wins ticket sales.

The Day of Revelation — Strange days, steady receipts.

The Furious — Fast cars, modest meters.

The Death of Robin Hood — Not gentle. Not quiet.